Women In Engineering Teams: Where Are The Numbers?
In raw numbers, are there actually more technical women in industry now than before? Is the percentage of women in engineering going up? What’s working? Is anything? Does anybody know?By Tracy Chou (Engineer, Pinterest & Mentor, Hackbright Academy)
The first Grace Hopper conference was held in 1994, bringing together 500 technical women. The second was in 1997. It’s since become an annual tradition, with attendance rising steeply in recent years: 2.9k in 2011, 3.6k in 2012, 4.6k in 2013. This is encouraging! Yay girl geeks! Definitely does compute!
But wait —
In raw numbers, are there actually more technical women in industry now than before? Is the percentage of women in engineering going up? What’s working? Is anything? Does anybody know?
We do know there’s a leaky pipeline of women in engineering (well documented in the book Unlocking the Clubhouse). Not enough girls are taking math and science classes in elementary school. Even fewer are enrolled in computer science classes in high school. By college, women constitute less than 12% of graduating CS majors.
What’s not clear is what happens when the graduates go off to industry. Do they stay in technical roles? Do they shift into non-technical roles in tech? Do they leave tech altogether?
A 2011-2013 CNN investigation into diversity at top U.S. tech companies turned up nothing but an industry-wide unwillingness to release any workforce diversity data. Some out-of-date sources cite Google’s percentage of female engineers at 20%, but I couldn’t find any explanation of this old stat (which seems high) or anything at all from other valley titans like Facebook.
I’ve inquired at a couple of well-known startups: one of them started counting women in business development, another included women in the product org generally, each saying that those teams were so integrated with engineering that it didn’t make sense to separate out the functions. Every company has some way of hiding or muddling the data on women actually in engineering roles.
The actual numbers I’ve seen and experienced in industry are far lower than anybody is willing to admit. This means nobody is having honest conversations about the issue. While companies do talk about their initiatives to make the work environment more female-friendly, or to encourage more women to go into or stay in computing, there’s no way of judging whether they’re successful or worth mimicking, because there are no success metrics attached to any of them.
But it’s hard for companies to admit that they’re working through any issues when they want to paint the rosy picture for recruiting. The competition for tech talent is fierce, and companies are inevitably pitted against each other fighting for good candidates, even more so for good female candidates because of their paucity. While it’s ok to say in a generic way that the industry has a long way to go, companies always need to at least intimate that they’re doing better than average.
I recognize that conflict of interest. At the same time, as an engineer and someone who’s had “data-driven design” browbeaten into me by Silicon Valley, I can’t imagine trying to solve a problem where the real metrics, the ones we’re setting our goals against, are obfuscated. Vanity metrics are dangerous; just pointing to the happy numbers, like those on Grace Hopper conference attendance, doesn’t do anything except make people feel good while the real issues fester, unaddressed.
We’ve all set up our booths at the Grace Hopper career fair and we’re all trying to recruit the same talented young women, but really — there’s a bigger goal, to remove gender as the hidden (or sometimes not-so-hidden) discriminant in the tech industry. And we need to work together to make that happen, and it starts with having honest dialogues about how we’re actually doing, as an industry, to encourage women in computing.
So where are the numbers?
I’ll start. Pinterest has 11 women out of 89 engineers, putting us at 12% female in engineering — the same percentage as coming out of undergraduate CS programs. Our inaugural intern class had 8 women out of 28 engineering interns, which is 29%. Many people ask me if it’s easier because we’re Pinterest. It’s not, really. We have to be thoughtful about sourcing candidates and building the right culture, and we invest in deliberate efforts to connect with women in the community. We’re still learning and growing, and we can get better about measuring and understanding our funnels as well. But we’re eager to open the conversation.
I set up a Github repo to track numbers that people are submitting: https://github.com/triketora/women-in-software-eng.
Please contribute data if you can! I also know there is bias in the companies that are willing to share their numbers; another way to help is by collecting data from publicly available data sources, like about/team pages for startups.
This post was originally posted at Tracy Chou's blog.
Recent Posts
CATEGORIES
- News (161)
- Hackbright Academy (123)
- Hackbright News (106)
- Profiles of Woman Engineers (105)
- Alum (98)
- Engineering Advice (68)
- tech (54)
- career change (53)
- Resources (49)
- TGIF (49)
- link roundup (49)
- reading (49)
- recap (49)
- roundup (49)
- weekly (49)
- women in tech (43)
- Becoming A Software Engineer (36)
- female software engineers (36)
- Software Engineer (35)
- diversity in tech (35)
- change the ratio (32)
- learn to code (31)
- Career Services (30)
- Admissions Office (28)
- women who code (28)
- #ilooklikeanengineer (27)
- Student Blogs (25)
- Hackbright Field Trips (24)
- female engineers (24)
- coding (23)
- Hackbright Mentors (22)
- Python (22)
- Thought Piece (21)
- Video (21)
- partner (20)
- diversity (18)
- Recruiting & Hiring (16)
- alumna (14)
- hackbright (13)
- tech inclusion (13)
- Software Engineers (11)
- hired (11)
- Graduation (10)
- changetheratio (10)
- Tech Talk (9)
- how to become a software engineer (9)
- software developer (9)
- Imposter Syndrome (8)
- hiring (8)
- Course Report (7)
- Facebook (7)
- GitHub (7)
- Hackbright Alumnae Showcase (7)
- Mentorship (7)
- Scholarship (7)
- women engineers (7)
- Hackbright mentor (5)
- Liz Howard (5)
- Programming Languages (5)
- Scholarships (5)
- coding bootcamp (5)
- mentor (5)
- recruiting (5)
- Admissions (4)
- Eventbrite (4)
- Full-Stack (4)
- Graduates (4)
- Hackathon (4)
- Heroku (4)
- Melanie Warrick (4)
- Mentors (4)
- Nicole Zuckerman (4)
- Resume (4)
- Silicon Chef (4)
- developer (4)
- holidays (4)
- instructor (4)
- women in computer science (4)
- Ada Lovelace Day (3)
- Chris Palmer (3)
- Code of Conduct (3)
- GoDaddy (3)
- Google (3)
- Halloween (3)
- Interview Tips (3)
- Jasmine Tsai (3)
- Job Search (3)
- Kathryn King (3)
- Mica Swyers (3)
- Negotiation (3)
- Pat Poels (3)
- STEM (3)
- Shilpa Dalmia (3)
- code (3)
- computer programming (3)
- day in the life (3)
- day-to-day (3)
- engineering (3)
- girls in tech (3)
- holidaze (3)
- international women's day (3)
- learning (3)
- part-time (3)
- prep (3)
- “Kelley Robinson” (3)
- ActivityHero (2)
- Aimee Morgan (2)
- Alyson La (2)
- Angie Chang (2)
- Arduino (2)
- Change.org (2)
- Elissa Murphy (2)
- Financing Options (2)
- Girls Who Code (2)
- Gowri Grewal (2)
- Gulnara Mirzakarimova (2)
- Hackathons (2)
- Inspiration (2)
- Joyce Park (2)
- Julia Grace (2)
- Julia Hartz (2)
- Kate Heddleston (2)
- Katherine Fellows (2)
- Katherine Hennes (2)
- Lisa Lee (2)
- Liz Crawford (2)
- Machine Learning (2)
- Marissa Mayer (2)
- Meagan Gamache (2)
- Megan Speir (2)
- Michelle Glauser (2)
- Michelle Sun (2)
- Natalie Downe (2)
- New Relic (2)
- Niniane Wang (2)
- Padmasree Warrior (2)
- Poornima Vijayashanker (2)
- Programming (2)
- Rebecca Bruggman (2)
- Security Engineering (2)
- Selina Tobaccowala (2)
- SheCodes (2)
- Siena Aguayo (2)
- SurveyMonkey (2)
- Tindie (2)
- Uber (2)
- Uncategorized (2)
- Web Apps (2)
- Zendesk (2)
- Zoe Kay (2)
- almnae (2)
- back-end (2)
- bootcamp (2)
- career transition (2)
- careers (2)
- coding blonde (2)
- coding school (2)
- computer programmer (2)
- ebook (2)
- engineer (2)
- financial aid (2)
- gender (2)
- gender gap (2)
- gift guide (2)
- hackbright prep (2)
- jobs after bootcamp (2)
- payment plans (2)
- podcast (2)
- product management (2)
- projects (2)
- python 101 (2)
- python programmers (2)
- reddit (2)
- social impact (2)
- students (2)
- techhire (2)
- technical product management (2)
- white house (2)
- women (2)
- women in STEM (2)
- #HackentinesDay (1)
- #hackdisrupt (1)
- #learntocode (1)
- 2017 (1)
- A Day In The Life Of A Hackbright Student (1)
- Academia.edu (1)
- Ada Lovelace (1)
- Adora Cheung (1)
- Affectiva (1)
- Alison Gianotto (1)
- Allison Deal (1)
- Ambassadors (1)
- Ambassadors Program (1)
- Anna Billstrom (1)
- AppJamming (1)
- Ashley Lorden (1)
- Automate Everything (1)
- Bay Area Girl Geek Dinners (1)
- BeMyApp Factory Hack (1)
- Belinda Runkle (1)
- Bessie Chu (1)
- Big O Notation (1)
- Bills.com (1)
- Birchbox (1)
- Black Girls Code (1)
- Blameless Work Culture (1)
- Brittany Martin (1)
- Browser Extension (1)
- Buffer (1)
- B’Elanna Torres (1)
- CODE Documentary (1)
- CODE2040 (1)
- CTO (1)
- CTOs (1)
- Cara Marie Bonar (1)
- Career Day (1)
- Cathy Edwards (1)
- Charmy Chhichhia (1)
- Chegg (1)
- Chomp (1)
- Christian Fernandez (1)
- Christina Liu (1)
- Christina Pan (1)
- Christine Yen (1)
- Cisco (1)
- Clare Corthell (1)
- Code.org (1)
- CodeGirl (1)
- CodeShannon (1)
- Computer Security (1)
- Conferences (1)
- Costumes (1)
- Couchsurfing (1)
- Cynthia Dueltgen (1)
- Danica McKellar (1)
- Data (1)
- Data Science (1)
- Dave-To-Girl (1)
- Dave-To-Girl Ratio (1)
- DevBeat 2013 (1)
- Dominic Dagradi (1)
- Electric Imp (1)
- Email Signature (1)
- Emily Gasca (1)
- Engineering Culture (1)
- Erica Kwan (1)
- Erin Parker (1)
- Farnaz Ronaghi (1)
- Female CTOs (1)
- Femgineer (1)
- Future of Food Hackathon (1)
- Gayle Laakmann McDowell (1)
- Gemma Barlow (1)
- Go Against The Flow (1)
- Google I/O 2014 (1)
- Grace Hopper (1)
- Grace Hopper Celebration (1)
- Hacbright Academy (1)
- Hack Your Life (1)
- Hack(bright) for Good (1)
- Hackbright Girl Geek Dinner (1)
- Hackbright engineering fellow (1)
- Hardware (1)
- Harvey Mudd College (1)
- Homejoy (1)
- Hour of Code (1)
- Huffington Post (1)
- Hypatia (1)
- Indiegogo (1)
- Industry Insight (1)
- Ingrid Avendaño (1)
- Jason Huggins (1)
- JavaScript (1)
- Jibe (1)
- Job Seeker (1)
- Jocelyn Goldfein (1)
- Joel Franusic (1)
- Kat Hagan (1)
- Kate Matsudaira (1)
- Katherine Wu (1)
- Katie Miller (1)
- Kaylee (1)
- Kelsey Yocum (1)
- Kimber Lockhart (1)
- Ksenia Burlachenko (1)
- LAUNCH Hackathon (1)
- Lauren Antonoff (1)
- Leap Motion (1)
- Lindsay Cade (1)
- LinkedIn (1)
- LinkedIn Profile (1)
- Lise Meitner (1)
- Lookout Mobile Security (1)
- Louise Fox (1)
- Maia Bittner (1)
- Margaret Le (1)
- Margaret Leibovic (1)
- Maria Klawe (1)
- Mariane Abou-Jaoudé (1)
- Marie Curie (1)
- Marissa Marquez (1)
- Martha Kelly (1)
- Math (1)
- Matt Haines (1)
- Mattermark (1)
- Meebo (1)
- Megan Anctil (1)
- Meggie Mahnken (1)
- Mercedes Coyle (1)
- Minted (1)
- Moms in Tech (1)
- Morgan Griggs (1)
- Mozilla (1)
- Music Information Retrieval (1)
- NCC Group (1)
- NESTA (1)
- Natasha Litt (1)
- Nidhi Kulkarni (1)
- Night Classes (1)
- Nishita Agarwal (1)
- Noah Kindler (1)
- Node (1)
- Node.js (1)
- Noise (1)
- O’Reilly (1)
- PandaWhale (1)
- Parse (1)
- Part-time classes (1)
- Perforce (1)
- PickAxe Mobile (1)
- Pinterest (1)
- Platform API (1)
- Popforms (1)
- Powers of Two (1)
- Presidential Innovation Fellow (1)
- Programming Interviews Exposed (1)
- PyCon 2014 (1)
- Quirky Eggs (1)
- Raji Arasu (1)
- Rana el Kaliouby (1)
- Raspberry Pi (1)
- Rebecca Parsons (1)
- RocksBox (1)
- Rosalind Franklin (1)
- Rosette Diaz (1)
- Ruby (1)
- Ruby on Rails (1)
- Sandra Lerner (1)
- Sandy Jen (1)
- Sarah Allen (1)
- Sarah Mei (1)
- Science and Technology (1)
- Security Engineer (1)
- Selenium (1)
- Shannon Burns (1)
- She Started It (1)
- Shiv Kumar (1)
- Smithsonian (1)
- Software Testing (1)
- Spitfire Athlete (1)
- Square (1)
- Stephanie Shupe (1)
- Steve Tjoa (1)
- StubHub (1)
- Student (1)
- Tech Gives Back (1)
- Testing (1)
- The Developers (1)
- ThoughtWorks (1)
- Tom Croucher (1)
- Toxicity (1)
- Tracy Chou (1)
- Twilio (1)
- TwilioQuest (1)
- Twitter (1)
- Velocity Conference 2014 (1)
- Vida Ha (1)
- Warren Colbert (1)
- Washington DC (1)
- Web Developer (1)
- Wendy Saccuzzo (1)
- Women TechMakers (1)
- Work Culture (1)
- Zainab Ghadiyali (1)
- Zed Shaw (1)
- ada (1)
- all-women (1)
- alumna spotlight (1)
- alumnae (1)
- alumni (1)
- app (1)
- be brave get paid (1)
- bias (1)
- black leaders (1)
- blog (1)
- bloomberg (1)
- career strategist (1)
- catalyst (1)
- checkr (1)
- codecademy (1)
- coderpad (1)
- coding interviews (1)
- collaborative coding (1)
- conference (1)
- corporate (1)
- costume (1)
- documentaries (1)
- edie windsor (1)
- education (1)
- efective communication (1)
- employer sponsorship (1)
- engineers (1)
- entrepreneur (1)
- fall2014 (1)
- fellowship (1)
- female founders (1)
- field trip (1)
- finance (1)
- fintech (1)
- firebase (1)
- front-end (1)
- genentech (1)
- getting started (1)
- girl power (1)
- git (1)
- giving back (1)
- gynopedia (1)
- hack bright (1)
- hacker (1)
- hacksmart2018 (1)
- implicit bias (1)
- infographic (1)
- information security (1)
- infosec (1)
- integration (1)
- internship (1)
- interviews (1)
- intro to programming (1)
- jobhunting (1)
- kids code (1)
- leadership (1)
- lesbians who tech (1)
- lwt (1)
- notifica (1)
- onboarding (1)
- online python 101 (1)
- pair programming (1)
- phenomenal woman (1)
- pre-bootcamp (1)
- programmers (1)
- python web framework (1)
- run the world (1)
- salary (1)
- salary negotiation (1)
- san francisco (1)
- security consulting (1)
- self-documenting code (1)
- sf (1)
- sheroes (1)
- software engineering fellowship (1)
- south bay (1)
- starting your own business (1)
- startup (1)
- streak (1)
- superheroes (1)
- tech tips (1)
- technical interview (1)
- technologies (1)
- transition (1)
- tuition (1)
- unconscious bias (1)
- volunteering (1)
- work-life balance (1)
- wwc (1)
- zach haehn (1)
- zapier (1)
- “Versal” (1)